Your browser (Internet Explorer 6) is out of date. It has known security flaws and may not display all features of this and other websites. Learn how to update your browser.
X
Post

3 days with the iPad

Well, it has now been two full days with the iPad and I figured I ought summarize some of my thoughts about it so far. I ought to preface his by saying that I had/have a healthy degree of skepticism regarding the device. I’m no Fanboy when it comes to Apple. I have a great appreciation for what they’ve accomplished, but I held off for years before switching to the iPhone. While I do have a MacBook, i still work primarily on a PC. And I have to admit, the list of things the iPad doesn’t do had me grinding my teeth.

And yet, I still wound up outside an Apple store at 6 am saturday morning with four other die hard Apple fans, watching dozens of Apple store employees prepare for heat seemed to be he event of the century. This was my first time coming out for an apple launch, and it was quite a spectacle. Screaming,cheering, high fives galore… And that was all from store employees! Starbucks came out and made up free coffee and passed out snacks. All in all, it really was quite a good time, if a bit overdone.

And after hours of waiting, I finally got the box in my hands, drove it home and ripped it open. A mixed blessing, it came with a full charge, but had to be connected to iTunes before it would work. So…….. if someone wanted this to be their one and only device, they need a friend with iTunes to activate it for them. Strange. It also started loading up all my iPhone apps, and I have quite a few. So despite the full charge, it was still about half an hour before I could play with it (which is freaking forever in ‘geek with a new toy’ time).

When I first got it fired up and running…. I have to admit i was a .title disappointed. ‘big iTouch’ kept going through my head. And while it’s nice to be able to runthe iodine apps, that double size thing is mostly annoying. However, I did discover something interesting pretty quick. The keyboard on the double size iPhone apps is easier to use than either of the iPad keyboards. Why? Because it sits closer to the ,idle of the screen. The iPad keyboards sit so low that it’s uncomfortable to hold it up and thumb type. Much more comfortable with the keyboard closer to the ,idle. That being said, I still deleted most of my native iPhone apps. It’s such a beautiful device, it seemed a shame to use those blocky, pixelly apps.

Anyway, as I was saying, I was disappointed at first. But an hour or so later, I needed to show my wife a recipe. So I grabbed the ipad and had it up in a second and was showing it to her in the kitchen. That was kind of nice. Much more convenient than booting up the laptop and calling her over. Not much, but that was the first lightbulb going on.

Later I gave it to Aiden to see what he would think of it. I was expecting some kind of wow moment, and I really didn’t get it. He just grabbed hold of it and knew exactly what to do. He flipped through the pages of apps and loaded up a game. When he got bored, he exited out and fired up the Toy Story interactive book and proceeded to watch the entire thing. The ,sot fascinating thing about it was just how intuitive it was for him. No instruction necessary, he knew just what to do. In some sense, that actually was kind of magical. It’s a new niche built on a familiar platform. He was careful, respectful and left much smaller fingerprints than mine.

I really started to see the potential when I brought it over to a friend’s house to watch the final four. I put it in the ,idle of the coffee table and just left it there to see how it would get used. And it got used constantly. People used it to look up sports facts, the Hawkeye football schedule, camp sites for a summer trip, the calendar to plan the same trip, the Lollapalooza lineup, to watch letterman use the iPad on YouTube, to check out a recipe, look up photos and who know what else. All I know is that it was used constantly. Yes, at first because it was a new gadget, but then because it was… Simple. Easy. Convenient. Intuitive. Accessible. And that’s when I started to really see where this thing is going. It’s a social machine because it CAN be. Try huddling sound an iPhone and having three people watch a video. Or passing an open laptop around a sofa. Can it be done? Sure! But this just does it… better.

Since then, I’ve used it for two more days and a good part has bee setting it up. Syncing calendars, getting email accounts up, installing apps, loading music and movies and so on. But I’ve also read stories to Aiden on it and started reading my own book as well. I’ve done more Thant my fair share of web surfing on it, which is quite simply a pleasure. I’ve read and sent emails, as well as done some actual work on it. And right now, I’m typing this post on it. It’s lying din in the sofa and I’m doing the fastest two finger typing i’ve ever done. I could do it faster with a real keyboard, but I wanted to try this out. And it ain’t too bad,

So what’s the verdict? I dunno. I can’t recommend someone buy it especially in place of a different device. But k can tell you I don’t regret the decision so far. And i can also say that while the apps are good so far, most were designed off a simulator. I’m confident they’ll get a lot better now that people can develop with production models. And as we saw witness the iPhone, the hardware was a good start, but it was the apps that really made the device. And this will be a dream of a platform to develop for.

So as of now, I’m satisfied with the experience as it is, and I see big potential for it. A s for it’s implications for education, I think the verdict is distill out. It really ain’t a cheap device, and the question is whether the benefits will justify the cost. Believe me, I’ll be coming back to that.

All things in time. As of the first three days, it may not be as magical as Jobs claimed… but i don’t think that’s a bad thing. Some times the best magic is the kind that’s simply invisible.

  • Thanks for what feels like a realistic review. Overall, I agree. There seems to be potential for it to be an expensive, big iPod Touch. It is what it is. I’d love to watch a Twins game on it, of course that’s what the big TV is for. Or my laptop.

    (I thought your choice of “boot” when talking about your laptop was interesting, though. Do you really shut down your laptop at home? And why would she have to leave the kitchen to look at your laptop? I have to guess we’re talking about single-digit seconds difference between me opening my Macbook and finding a recipe vs. unlocking the iPad and finding one. Not to mention, what if she wanted to use the recipe? Lay the iPad flat on the counter? I have my MacBook in the kitchen while we make dinner almost every night.)

    I’m sure if I had one around the house it would get used. As someone who doesn’t have $500 of “fun money” to spend, I don’t see myself saving up for it, though. Besides, the only model that interest me is the 3G model (grandparents are each 2+ hours away) so now we’re talking $630 with data on top.

    For me what it lacks — a has been beaten to death — is what really stands out. I have a two-month-old son. When we were visiting my parents this weekend, they asked my opinion on if they should look into an iPad. I asked what they wanted to do with it. First thing out of their mouth was “Skype!”

    Typing on it for a few minutes at the Apple Store, I was instantly shocked that Apple still hasn’t implemented haptic feedback on the keyboard. Maybe it’s coming with OS 4.0, but wow.

    Here’s my real problem: the iPad represents everything that’s gone wrong with Apple. It is the ultimate closed device. It’s “computer sized” (compared to the iPhone) and yet it is both literally and figuratively closed. There is no sense of ownership. I get to use what Apple permits on the only hardware Apple permits. It reminds me of how schools have gotten into the mess we’re currently in: close the classroom door, now open your brains, kids, while I fill you up with what I deem relevant.

    I went into the Apple Store with my wife and son tonight and caught myself about 10 seconds after picking up an iPad with my mouth agape. Then I tried moving around the icons. The Apple Store had locked that down. I tried typing. Without feedback it wasn’t enjoyable. It’s not that it wasn’t doable, it wasn’t magical or astonishing or whatever Steve wanted it to be. It was frustrating. I opened up Pages so I could type and couldn’t figure out how to do anything to the document besides look at it. Turns out, I was in landscape and you can only edit in portrait. First time I’ve had to ask for help with an Apple product in my life — and I’ve been a geek since I was running Number Munchers on our IIgs when I was 6.

    I’m sad. As someone who is still running a 1,1 MacBook and sold the Wii I stayed overnight in an Iowa December to get to buy a first generation iPhone for $400, I’m sad. The iPad is really disappointing to me. It’s a tiny evolution, but the culture around Jobs has allowed it to be the front runner in conversations it should not be in. The iPad in education? It’s a textbook! The iPad to replace my laptop? Give me a break!

    :D eep breath:

    I’m glad you wrote your review, Steve. Someone needs to balance out the blowhards like me.

    Russ Goerend

    4/5/2010

  • @teach42- 3 days with the iPad http://bit.ly/bzNmz3 Great summary and loved Steve's typos, as he did his blog entry on the iPad. #ipad

    Randy Lyseng

    4/6/2010

  • RT @teach42: 3 days with the iPad http://bit.ly/bzNmz3

    kathy pryor

    4/6/2010

  • Great review. I’m really thinking about picking one up today.

    It really does feel like a sort of disruptive tool to me. It’s something that isn’t quite perfect but suggests a sea change in how information can be accessed and used. – perhaps even created.

    It’s exciting to touch and use tools like this, and to see little hands find new possibilities as well. That’s worth the price of admission to me.

    Andy Kohl

    4/6/2010

  • @Russ Your response is got too long and is going to be a new blog post!

    Steve Dembo

    4/6/2010

  • Thanks Steve for your review of the iPad. I really laughed out loud at this line “So despite the full charge, it was still about half an hour before I could play with it (which is freaking forever in ‘geek with a new toy’ time).” I remember the day I brought my first iPhone home and had to wait for hours to activate it through iTunes. It made me wonder if I had made a mistake, but I truly do love my iPhone.

    I decided not to wait in line for hours when the iPad launched like I had done for my iPhone. I already have a PC laptop, a Mac Book, and a netbook, so I don’t feel the need to get an iPad right now. I’m letting the dust settle and reading and bookmarking thoughts by other users. Again thanks for your review.
    Paula Naugle´s last blog ..End of the School Year My ComLuv Profile

    Paula Naugle

    6/19/2010

  • Via Steve Dembo: 3 days with the iPad http://j.mp/8ZffhT

    John Larkin

    8/20/2010

  • Via Steve Dembo: 3 days with the iPad http://j.mp/8ZffhT

    MobileLearningSig

    8/20/2010

  • RT @john_larkin: Via Steve Dembo: 3 days with the iPad http://j.mp/8ZffhT

    Kwan Tuck Soon

    8/20/2010

Leave a comment  

name*

email*

website

Submit comment

CommentLuv Enabled