I got an email alerting me to a segment on CBS News about one school using a GPS tracking device to help stop truancy.
While it may have worked for the student in the video, I have to admit some skepticism regarding the ability for this to be a large scale solution. They mention that the student really does want to be in school, and this provides him an excuse to provide his friends, without losing any reputation points.
However, there had to be reasons beyond just peer pressure that caused him to miss so many days int he first place. And if the school doesn’t address those issues, then why should this make any difference. Yes, we do want the student to be in his/her seat. But we also need to find new ways to motivate those students, to keep them involved in their education, to ensure that it’s relevant and valuable to their future success. While I’m not trying to imply that the school in the video is failing to do that, I do want to point out that getting them there is only one part of a larger solution to the problem.
And is anybody else wondering what’s to stop him from just putting the darn device into someone else’s backpack for the day?
6/13/2008
That’s odd…off my RSS reader the embedded video is no longer available. Instead CBS has put up a notice that says, ‘We’re sorry, the selected clip is no longer available. For more videos, please visit our site.’ Yet when I click to go directly to the post on your blog the embedded video is there….hmmmmmm Wonder what’s up with that.
You gots those friendly e-mails letting you know about the GPS thing too, eh? I ignored the first read, but went back to read it after I got the second one.
Seems like half a step away from parolees wearing ankle bracelets to keep them at home; stupid, stupid, stupid waste of money to tell students that school is SO boring we’re treating you like felons to force you to go.
Yep. I’d clip it to a nerds back pack then get it back at the end of the day. Simple solution.
Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI
Leave a comment









Flickr/teach42
Myspace/teach42
Facebook/Steve Dembo
Linkedin/teach42
Twitter/teach42
YouTube/teach42
Del.icio.us/teach42
GMail/Steve Dembo
Technorati/teach42
MyBlogLog/teach42



3 Comments