May 08
Digg
Stumbleupon
Technorati
Delicious

6 Billion Dollars… to maintain status quo?

Like him or loathe him, you can always guarantee that Gary Stager will make you think. In his most recent post, he has opened my eyes to issues that I have to admit I was woefully ignorant of, namely the recently released results of a study on the Impact of Reading First. To summarize it would do it a great disservice, so I recommend you go there and read it yourself.

A couple of quotes tho.

The recent report concludes, “Reading First did not improve students’ reading comprehension… The program did not increase the percentages of students in grades one, two or three whose reading comprehension scores were at or above grade level.” In other words, a $6 billion federal program spending had no positive impact. Additionally, local school districts have made inestimable investments to support Reading First.

The failure of Reading First represents more than a course correction for a well-intentioned attempt to benefit the nation’s children. Reading First was rife with politics, contempt for professional educators and conflicts of interest from the outset. It is particularly ironic that an administration insistent that every classroom practice must adhere to “scientifically-based research,” to the exclusion of research it did not like, continues to insist that Reading First should be the law of the land, despite its own evidence to the contrary.

Well worth taking the time to read.


Author: Steve

1 Comment(s)

Lee
5/12/2008

Well this just goes to show that statistics do not always show the whole picture. My district has found great success with Reading First (we may not have been following the script to the letter). We have seen vast improvements in our elementary reading scores. In fact of our 6 elementary school, 4 of which were labeled as failing have all made AYP thanks in great part to Reading First. So say what you want, but Reading First was not a total waste and in fact for us was a huge success.

Lee’s most recent blog post.. Another Voice Joins the Chorus

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment